The Main Camp Problem: A Full Exposé of How Families Are Being Misled
By Mike Butters | Founder, Hockey Horizons | Hockey Hits
I have written about this before and I will write about it again because the problem has not gone away and the families being exploited by it deserve as much clarity as I can provide. The misuse of the term Main Camp in junior hockey is one of the most pervasive and most financially harmful practices in the industry, and it continues because most families do not know enough about how rosters are built to recognize when they are being misled.
Let me be direct about what a genuine main camp is and is not. A genuine main camp is the final pre-season evaluation process through which an organization determines its roster for the coming season. It is attended by a combination of returning players, previously committed recruits, and a targeted group of prospects for the genuinely open roster spots. The ratio of attendees to available spots should be reasonable — a team carrying 23 players with eight open spots should have roughly fifteen to twenty-five players competing for those spots, not eighty. The coaching staff should be fully present and genuinely evaluating. And the financial arrangement should reflect the fact that organizations can conduct legitimate evaluations without charging players for the privilege of trying out.
What many organizations call a Main Camp is none of these things. It is a revenue-generating event in which organizations invite as many players as will pay the fee — sometimes fifty, eighty, or a hundred players — knowing that the majority of their roster is already determined and that the genuine open competition is for one or two spots at most. The marketing language creates the impression of a genuine opportunity. The financial transaction creates the impression of serious organizational investment. The reality is that most players attending these events are paying for a tryout that was never going to result in a roster spot.
The goaltender version of this problem deserves special emphasis. A team carries two goaltenders. A legitimate main camp evaluation process for goalies involves six to eight goaltenders competing for those two spots — that is a reasonable, evaluable number that allows the coaching staff to genuinely assess each candidate. When a main camp has twelve, fifteen, or twenty goalies, the organization is not conducting a genuine evaluation — it is generating goaltender camp fee revenue. Every goalie family should ask organizations directly and specifically how many goaltenders are being invited before committing to attend.
Protecting Your Family From This Practice
The questions that protect families from the Main Camp exploitation are direct and non-negotiable. Before attending any camp: how many roster spots are genuinely open at my player's position? How many players are being invited to compete for those spots? Have you already committed players to this roster for the coming season, and if so, how many? Which specific members of the coaching staff will be present throughout the evaluation? What is the policy on camp refunds if the player is not offered a contract? Organizations that cannot or will not answer these questions specifically and honestly have given you the information you need about whether this camp is worth your time and money.
Hockey Horizons exists to give players and families the honest, experienced guidance that the junior hockey world rarely provides. If anything in this article raised questions about your player's situation, reach out. That is exactly what we are here for.
For guidance on the complete development picture, visit us at hockeyhorizons.com.




Comments